For several weeks, I’ve been experimenting with a couple recipes to make the best pizza I can from scratch at home. I’ve gotten it pretty good after a lot of trial and error. This is what I’ve come up with.
For the crust, I use the following recipe for a deep-dish dough, which is no different than the one I previously posted. I just figured out the best way to bake it.
1 1/3 cup water
2 teaspoons sugar
1 1/4 teaspoons salt
2 tablespoons olive oil
2 tablespoons cornmeal
2 cups unbleached all purpose flour
1 cup bread flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
1/4 teaspoon onion powder
3/8 teaspoon MSG (optional)
1 1/2 teaspoons yeast(You may use all-purpose flour for this recipe if doing it by hand).
Bread machine: Add ingredients to machine bread pan in order given or as per manufacturer’s instructions. Set to ‘dough’ mode.
Since the original post, I have tried with MSG (a product called “Accent”), it doesn’t seem to add enough to the taste to recommend it. I also found a much better way to bake it. Almost as important as the ingredients themselves is how you prepare this. It is best to have a pan that is made for deep-dish pizzas. Mine is about a 12″ metal (aluminum?) pan that I bought online from a restaurant supply website. I let the bread machine do it’s thing, and then take it out when it is done (when it beeps). Before putting it in the pan, I add about 3 tablespoons of vegetable oil to the pan. This is important – don’t just spray it with Pam and call it good. 3 Tbps of oil is more than what’s needed to keep the dough from sticking to the pan, it also served the purpose of frying the dough a little while it’s in the oven, which results in a much better tasting crust. Once the pan is oiled, put the dough in it and press it out to fill the pan. Leave the edges a little thicker than the middle to give a nice crust edge when it’s done baking. Then give it another hour or so to rise some more before adding sauce, cheese, and toppings.
For sauce, we used the Ragu stuff you can buy by the gallon at Sam’s club for about $3 for years. It works, but it makes a pretty pathetic pizza. Spend a little extra money and get some good sauce. Our local grocery store stocks sauce from several local chains, including Green Mill, Davani’s, and Rocky Rococco. We like the Green Mill the best, but any of them are better than the Ragu (I’d rate the Ragu about 3 out of 10 and the worst of the chain sauces about a 7). However, if you really want a good sauce that you make yourself from scratch, I created the following recipe after a bit of experimenting that is quite good:
1 (8 oz.) can of Tomato Sauce
1 (6 oz.) can of Tomato Paste
1 Tablespoon Olive Oil
1 teaspoon Sugar
1/2 teaspoon Salt
1/2 teaspoon Basil
1/2 teaspoon Oregano
1/2 teaspoon Garlic Powder
1/4 teaspoon Onion Powder
1/8 teaspoon Black PepperJust mix it all together and apply to your pizza crust. You’ll get a lot more out of this recipe than you need for one pizza. Depending on how much you like to put on, you may be able to get two pizzas out of it.
We have a convection oven, and I like to bake the pizza at 375 degrees for about 15 minutes, but your millage may vary. My experience with the convection oven is that it bakes about twice as fast as a normal oven. If you don’t have convection, I would guess it would take about 25 minutes to bake, but that is just a guess. It’s a homemade recipe, so pick a temp and keep an eye on it.
Of course the cheese and toppings are up to you. Everyone likes their pizza their own way. I like to fry up a bunch of bacon, tear it into small pieces after it’s cooked, and have pepperoni and bacon pizza.
You may have to experiment a little until you get it the way you like it, that’s okay. A few mediocre pizzas is worth getting it figured out. Now that I have it down, I like my pizza every bit as much as a restaurant pizza.

Sunday was a day at sea, chuggin’ our way toward the Dominican Republic. We sailed right down the north coast of Cuba, and could often times see it off the right side of the ship. This was a day to explore the ship and take advantage of what they had to offer. There was a kids center that we had hoped to take advantage of for Jude, but they required that kids be at least 2 and potty trained. Since Jude was neither, we didn’t get to use it. Interestingly, they didn’t allow parents in there, so we probably wouldn’t have used it anyway since Jessica cherishes her time with Jude and wouldn’t part with him anyway. They did have a sort-of program for those under two. They called it “under two zoo.” It was basically a bunch of toys set aside in a conference room and a door left open for those interested. Jessica liked it, I preferred finding a good place on the ship to let Jude run free, the promenade and the pool deck were good places. They also had a kids pool area complete with water slides. Signs stated that only potty-trained children were allowed, but they seemed to turn a blind-eye to smaller kids so we took advantage. Jude loved it, and even enjoyed doing the water slides himself – with no assistance from us.
In Samana, we didn’t know what to do on our own, so we broke with our standard procedures and booked an excursion with the ship. We went on a boat tour of mangrove forests and some interesting caves (which you get out of the boat to see), followed by some time at the beach on a private island owned by a hotel. Jessica really hoped to catch a glimps of some sea lions, as they had a program (we didn’t want to pay for) with sea lions. Funny enough, while she was off looking for a restroom, a couple people walked up the beach with a sea lion following along. She missed it and they never returned. Another funny thing was that as the boat was heading toward the island after the tour, we hit rain. We stopped long enough for them to pass out rain coats, and then carried on. Shortly after the rain coats were all on, and we resumed the trip, the rain stopped.
The walk itself was reasonable, but the sidewalk ended and the road narrowed, making the last leg a bit scary. Once we got there, we had to wait around for our time to start, as we were about 80 minutes early. That was alright though, as the dolphins were fun to watch, and there were a few people from the ship we got to meet and chat with. Once our time came, things got rough though. They had us waiting a while for the program to start. Jessica was not happy, and her snottiness started to show. She said to me, intentionally loud enough for them to hear, that she was ready to ask for a refund and leave. Once it started, all was well though. We had booked the cheapest program available, since Jude was with and wasn’t allowed to do the things available in more expensive packages. What we paid for was to kiss the dolphin, pet it, dance with it a little, and have an interesting show. The next package up involved a swim, where the dolphin pulls you along. We found out once we got going that people with different packages were mixed together, and we could have easily done the swim. Each of us would hold Jude while the other swam. I said to Jessica, “We should have done that.” The lady that was directing us when out of the water (and filming the program) must have heard me say it because she whispered something to the trainer, who turned and asked if I’d like to do the swim. I jumped at it! In the end, it was a lot of fun. We didn’t brave the narrow roads back though. Another couple in our group was also on the cruise with us so we split a cab back to the ship. Once we were back, we had a quick lunch, gave Jude some time for a short nap, and headed out to look at souvenirs at the little flea market set up near the ship. Jude had fun there because there are a lot of wild chickens on Tortola, and he thought that chasing them was the thing to do!
Then we headed to “Blackbeard’s Castle”, an old Dutch fortress (more of a tower) breifly under the control of the pirate. We took a cab there, and walked through the whole area, which had more to see than we cared to take time to check out, including many colonial era homes and buildings. Part of the attraction is the “99 steps” also, which lead down from the fortress. Once at the bottom of the hill, we were in downtown Charlotte Amalie, capital of the U.S. Virgin Islands. We didn’t stick around long, but walked about a mile back to the ship for lunch and another nap for Jude, before heading to Magen’s Bay. Magen’s is touted as one of National Geographic’s top 10 beaches in the world. I liked it. It was beautiful, though crowded, and the waters were nice. After just a couple hours we opted to head back to the ship though, and it was a good thing we did. We left plenty of time to get back, or so we thought. We were supposed to be back by 4:30 and it was a little after 3:00. Traffic was bad though, and we ended up jumping out of the cab (more of a tour bus), paying the driver, and walking the last half mile. We got aboard the ship right at 4:30. Then we decided to head straight for the promenade so we could watch the stragglers and see how late they allowed people to be. It wasn’t until about 5:05 when the last gang-plank was lifted and the doors closed.